This started when I was to give a professor a CD of some software he needed. I put it in a Nina Simone jewel case. He noticed, and we talked briefly about the merits of the CD (it was a compilation). That evolved into a the question: “You like jazz?” and ended with him offering me two tickets to Friday’s performance at the CSO. You never know who you’re going to meet in this world, I suppose.
Joshua Redman was the headliner, I’m sure, but opening was a young woman named Anat Cohen. A quick read of her bio identifies her as a relative newcomer, arriving in New York City in 1999. Her multi-ethnic trio powered their way through four compositions and about 40 minutes of play time. What struck me most was her energy, a quality that isn’t so easily captured on studio recordings. She would catch the beat and happily bounce in place with clarinet in hand.
A slow piece, an Brazillian composition, and a couple of selections from the album she had just put out rounded her evening. What was apparent that, sometimes she would miss her lead in, and the band would have to come back around to pick her up. At those times, she would grin at her bandmates and keep her foot tapping. She introduced the band twice, obviously happy to share the spotlight. An insert in the program indicated that she’s be in the lobby after the show, and she was, beaming and talking excitedly to new fans.
After a short intermission, Joshua Redman and his James Farm project took the stage. One of the things that bugs me about jazz shows is the fact that the temptation is always there for a big name to phone it in, assured that their place in the canon and the grand pantheon of American music has assured them of another sizable paycheck. In my opinion, Redman didn’t phone it in. But you wouldn’t have known it from the audience’s reaction.
What DID happen, though, is that a LOT of people left. Early. In the middle of the second composition, the exodus started. After he played his last, the crowd on the main floor was about half standing O and half packing the aisles. Even as he came back out for an encore, people did not scramble back to their seats in a madcap rendition of musical chairs; they were headed to Michigan Avenue and all points that were not Symphony Hall.
In our usual seats in the Gallery, you only tackle those Alps-like stairs when you’re sure the show is done. In this Other World we had inhabited for the evening, the lack of stairs emboldened people to get up and leave. The show ended close to 11pm, so I assume that the time had something to do with the rate of exit. Was it Redman’s music? I don’t think so, although there were a few times were the effect would have been doubled if he’d played some passages louder or expounded on some seemingly lazy phrases, but it was what it was.
If anything, this evening introduced me to an artist I had previously not heard of and her music although,a s I mentioned before, I don’t know if her live presence translates well to anything but a live DVD, if only as testament to her energy. Redman? He didn’t suck, but he didn’t bring anything particularly challenging to us either. A lot of chord runs, a lot of discordant drumming and piano playing into which both Cohen and Redman would insert a few notes for significant parts of time.
All in all, my wife and I had a decent time, and we certainly appreciated being able to go.
